HIFI-FORUM » English » Surround (Engl.) » 5.1 vs 7.1 | |
|
5.1 vs 7.1+A -A |
||
Autor |
| |
juggy_25
Ist häufiger hier |
#1 erstellt: 20. Jan 2006, 17:33 | |
Hi I am planning to get an Onkyo TX-SR503 receiver with a 5.1 setup of Sonodyne Genie-IIs and Roarr 2815 subwoofer. 1. Is the Onkyo-Sonodyne a good combination? 2. Shud I go in for the Sonodyne AV300R (which is 5.1) or the Onkyo AVR(7.1)? I am planning on Onkyo coz its a 7.1 AVR, and the 5.1s wud be replaced by the 7.1 formats pretty soon, owing to the pace of technology advance. |
||
kvish
Ist häufiger hier |
#2 erstellt: 21. Jan 2006, 14:00 | |
There are very few Titles available in the market with 7.1 or even 6.1. Even if they are, they just mix few signals from the rear surrounds and bump them onto another channel... (not all... Check out for eg. Se7en special edition, they have optimized the sound for 6.1, meaning the 6th channel gives what it really should and not just add some sounds. but like I said earlier, there are very few available). I would say, listen to both in 5.1 and choose based on sound clarity and surround processing, if onkyo sounded better for you, the added channels are a Bonus! |
||
|
||
juggy_25
Ist häufiger hier |
#3 erstellt: 21. Jan 2006, 16:02 | |
thanx a lot kvish. i heard the sonodyne 5.1 AV-300 Receiver and it sounded just amazing. what puts me in a dilemma is if the formats quickly change to 7.1 in the near future, i wud be stuck with a 5.1 receiver, and i wud have to spend a hell lot to upgrade. does the 7.1 or 6.1 give a much better surround effect than 5.1? in short, what shud i go for.....5.1 recvr or the 7.1? (Note: The hall in my house is small) |
||
SDhawan
Stammgast |
#4 erstellt: 22. Jan 2006, 06:38 | |
Hi ! I have a 7.1 setup from Marantz and I find absolutely no advantage over 5.1 because: 1. I haven't come across even a single DVD in the market which is true 7.1 format 2. I wonder if the AVR actually any true internal 7.1 suporting decoding formats. It just has EX/ES which splits the sound of the two rear channels to feed into 4 rear channels. I suggest that you should look more at the quality 5.1 system. Regards Dr. Sanjay Dhawan |
||
juggy_25
Ist häufiger hier |
#5 erstellt: 22. Jan 2006, 07:34 | |
thanx Dr. which connections (component video/s-video/composite/audio) do u use to get the high quality picture and audio? what type of cables? I am presently in the US. shud I get any video/audio cables from here to enhance the picture and audio? |
||
nimz
Ist häufiger hier |
#6 erstellt: 22. Jan 2006, 15:30 | |
Hi.. even i was looking at the Onkyo 503 as it is 7.1 and future proof.. was looking at coupling with a Lithos 2.1 sub sat.. and later upgrading to a HT.. but the Sonodyne 5.1 processor and pre amp is getting a lot of mention.. now am in 2 minds.. whether to go for a Marantz / Onkyo 7.1 or a sonodyne.. pls help |
||
SDhawan
Stammgast |
#7 erstellt: 23. Jan 2006, 11:48 | |
Hi ! I use quality component cables for video from DVD to AVR to TV. And I use quality speaker cables from AVR to speakers and co-axial cable for digital audio connection between DVD & AVR. At present I see not much merit in 7.1 (over 5.1) system. BTW Marantz is not bad for 5.1 either. Regards Dr. Sanjay Dhawan |
||
juggy_25
Ist häufiger hier |
#8 erstellt: 23. Jan 2006, 15:25 | |
the onkyo TX-SR503 AV receiver gives 130W/ch, continuous 6 ohms. The Genie-II speakers works at 80W, 8 ohms. Will this difference in wattage between the AVR and speakers overload the speakers? shud I get more powerful speakers? |
||
abhi.pani
Inventar |
#9 erstellt: 24. Jan 2006, 08:34 | |
Hey Guys CAUTION !!!! dont get into the trick that if your reciever is 7.1 that means you can enjoy 7.1 formats of DVD. Its not like that. Your reciever should be able to DECODE authentic 7.1 surround formats as well. For that your reciever should have 7.1 surround decoder. For Example Dolby Digital is 5.1 surround format and if your 5.1 reciever doesnt have Dolby Digital decoder then even if you have 5 channels of amplification you wont get that surround Dolby effect and it will be like playing all the music into all the chaanels. Understand this simple fundamental thing that ONLY NUMBER OF CHANNELS OF AMPLIFICATION is not gonna give you any true surround sound, its the SURROUND DECODER which mixes the sound and feeds it appropriately to each channel. So thats the trick. Now I dont know any surround formats yet which creates true 7.1 surround sound so there is no question of your reciever supporting any 7.1 format at all. Hence there is no future proofing in that sense at all.............. |
||
nimz
Ist häufiger hier |
#10 erstellt: 25. Jan 2006, 13:36 | |
thanks Abhi.pani for that insight on decoders. Could u kindly throw some light on the impedance matching between AVR and spkrs? Should both have the same impedance? Reg wattage a 135w/ch Japanese amp should be more or less right for a 80 watt spkr. (Do correct me if am wrong) |
||
abhi.pani
Inventar |
#11 erstellt: 31. Jan 2006, 11:23 | |
Ya Nimz you are right. Basically Impedance matching is not all that important in AV recievers. If your reciever is rated at 100 watts at 8 ohms then it simply means, it can go upto 130 watts at 6 ohms (approx). It really doesnt matter so much in AV reciever as it matters in Pure Stereo Amplifier. Ultimately no speaker has its impedance constant while playing, its totally dynamic and infact it varies from 2-16 ohms while you are actually playing it....so its better you dont worry about it. Only thing to keep in mind is not to blast a 50 watt speaker using a 200 watt per channel reciever......it can definitely damage the drivers. |
||
|
|
Das könnte Dich auch interessieren: |
plz suggest 5.1 speakers for TX-SR503 juggy_25 am 26.01.2006 – Letzte Antwort am 08.02.2006 – 20 Beiträge |
HK AVR 235 or ONKYO TX-SR503 anirvan am 01.06.2005 – Letzte Antwort am 22.06.2005 – 23 Beiträge |
sonodyne cinque 5.1 kousik_s am 01.03.2006 – Letzte Antwort am 26.04.2006 – 27 Beiträge |
Marantz vs Sonodyne juggy_25 am 15.04.2006 – Letzte Antwort am 03.05.2006 – 39 Beiträge |
Onkyo TX-SR503 or TX-SR702 ?? juggy_25 am 30.01.2006 – Letzte Antwort am 30.01.2006 – 2 Beiträge |
onkyo HT-S670 anirvan am 19.04.2005 – Letzte Antwort am 18.05.2005 – 18 Beiträge |
Which Denon AVR & which speakers? SDhawan am 21.08.2004 – Letzte Antwort am 29.02.2016 – 13 Beiträge |
Speakers under 30K for Onkyo 503 ADM am 26.09.2005 – Letzte Antwort am 30.09.2005 – 10 Beiträge |
volume is weird for onkyo tx-sr702 lauradig am 05.02.2005 – Letzte Antwort am 07.02.2005 – 2 Beiträge |
Getting the right AVR... pls help nimz am 31.01.2006 – Letzte Antwort am 11.02.2006 – 43 Beiträge |
Foren Archiv
2006
Anzeige
Produkte in diesem Thread
Aktuelle Aktion
Top 10 Threads der letzten 7 Tage
- Hotel Modus deaktivieren
- "diese anwendung wird jetzt neu gestartet um mehr speicherplatz verfügbar zu machen"
- Von HD+ zurück zu Standard-TV
- Remotekabel anschließen, aber wie und wo?
- Hisense verbindet sich nicht mehr mit dem WLAN
- Audiodeskription ausschalten (in ZDF App) 803er
- Umschalten von TV auf Radio
- Satellitenschüssel was und wie einstellen am TV
- Pro 7 und Sat 1 auf einmal weg.
- Markierung an Lautsprecherkabel - welche Norm?
Top 10 Threads der letzten 50 Tage
- Hotel Modus deaktivieren
- "diese anwendung wird jetzt neu gestartet um mehr speicherplatz verfügbar zu machen"
- Von HD+ zurück zu Standard-TV
- Remotekabel anschließen, aber wie und wo?
- Hisense verbindet sich nicht mehr mit dem WLAN
- Audiodeskription ausschalten (in ZDF App) 803er
- Umschalten von TV auf Radio
- Satellitenschüssel was und wie einstellen am TV
- Pro 7 und Sat 1 auf einmal weg.
- Markierung an Lautsprecherkabel - welche Norm?
Top 10 Suchanfragen
Forumsstatistik
- Registrierte Mitglieder927.760 ( Heute: 1 )
- Neuestes Mitgliedgordonwilloughby
- Gesamtzahl an Themen1.556.430
- Gesamtzahl an Beiträgen21.658.633