HIFI-FORUM » English » Other hifi (Engl.) » CRTs vs Plasmas & LCDs | |
|
CRTs vs Plasmas & LCDs+A -A |
|||
Autor |
| ||
Krish
Stammgast |
06:16
![]() |
#1
erstellt: 10. Okt 2006, ||
Hi, My Tv a 29 inch Sony Kirara Basso, of '95 vintage is dying. I'm looking at a replacement.the question I have is this - Do Plasmas and LCD have better picture ? B&W, Colours esp reds... Also in your opinion which brand is a good bet. Cheers K |
|||
SDhawan
Stammgast |
18:56
![]() |
#2
erstellt: 10. Okt 2006, ||
Hi Krish ! To your questions I would like to add another one here. For screen sizes upto 29" what is the advantage of LCD or Plasma over CRT? Especially if we are not looking for HDMI compatibility. |
|||
|
|||
zhopudey
Stammgast |
20:02
![]() |
#3
erstellt: 10. Okt 2006, ||
^^Slimmer, cooler, and much more power efficient. Add bragging rights as per taste. |
|||
reignofchaos
Stammgast |
20:07
![]() |
#4
erstellt: 10. Okt 2006, ||
All depends on what you are going to watch... if its SD signals all the time, makes sense to go for a CRT/Rear projection instead of an LCD/Plasma. A standard definition interlaced signal would look atrocious on an lcd/plasma. If its HDTV/dvd/hd-dvd/bluray watching mostly, I'd buy an LCD in a heartbeat :). |
|||
Amp_Nut
Inventar |
05:33
![]() |
#5
erstellt: 11. Okt 2006, ||
Why not a Plasma ??? ![]() |
|||
Krish
Stammgast |
06:45
![]() |
#6
erstellt: 11. Okt 2006, ||
It's going to be mostly for C&S and movies.I do not see myself investing in a HD DVD or Blu Ray DVD player in the near future.The software for these formats neither going to be plentiful or cheap. My question on colour fidelity still stands.Does a CRT beat LCDs and Plasmas on that count.
Unfortunately I ain't the Onida type ![]() ![]() K |
|||
Kamal
Stammgast |
11:18
![]() |
#7
erstellt: 11. Okt 2006, ||
With the kind of usage you have outlined I think a 29" CRT should do for you in case you have a limited budget-do check out the Philips 29 " cost around 20K was very impressed by the picture quality. BTW, a friend who had picked up a plasma & was suffering awful quality thru cable, recently got a DTH connection-TataSky; the picture quality is unbelievable, even for doordarshan,just like DVD. So, if cost is not much of a consideration, you could think along these lines. Re Plasma vs LCD, as per the viewing experience, LCDs offer a sharper picture, while in Plasmas, the colour appears more vivid-however, the recent LCDs have caught up in picture depth-Sony's V series, Samsungs Bordeaux series. This was the conclusion while recently shopping around for large screen HDTV ready TVs-took around 2-3 good DVDs( Gladiator, Shakespear in love etc) and viewed them simultaneously on various makes of LCD/Plasma TVs. The Bordeaux was the final choice. |
|||
srikarkav
Ist häufiger hier |
17:31
![]() |
#8
erstellt: 11. Okt 2006, ||
Hi, The Sony is good only at the higher price end. You should either go for Panasonic Tau or Philips. One forum member says there is a Philips pixel plus for 24000. The Tau costs around 17000. cheers shri |
|||
stevieboy
Stammgast |
15:02
![]() |
#9
erstellt: 12. Okt 2006, ||
hi krish, plasma tv would offer better picture. shorter life cos of burn in on the glass. lcds longer life but to me the picture quality suffers a bit. i think lcds are also more power efficient. i hope its not the other way around. do check up on this. i'd second reignofchaos. an rptv any day over a plasma or lcd. somehow the picture seems so much more real. if you're going in for sony, the bravia range is supposed to be good. they're only focusing on lcds now though. they think its the way forward. you could pick up a test cd to check out the blacks, reds etc... assuming they're available here. regards |
|||
SDhawan
Stammgast |
15:53
![]() |
#10
erstellt: 12. Okt 2006, ||
Correct me if I'm wrong: -motion is depicted better in Plasma -Larger screen sizes - Plasma is better -Plasma has a wider viewing angle -Lip sync may be a problem in Plasma - so you need a DVD player or AVR with a lip-sync delay to match the PDP -The charge on the Plasma screen "misaligns the crystal" and so requires regular discharging / realignemnt |
|||
Kamal
Stammgast |
12:45
![]() |
#11
erstellt: 13. Okt 2006, ||
Sanjay, many of the earlier shortcomins have been"fixed" I personally verified that the viewing angle on the Sony & Samsung LCD TV Which were shortlisted was 178 Degrees!2. No motion blur in LCDs now- again personally verified.As regards the point that plasmas are better in large r sizes I cant comment on that bec the max size I was researching was 40". One Plasma dealer even printed a shootout of Plasma Vs LCD for me to convince me that plasmas are way better-the shootout was dated 2004! Thinks have certainly changed and technology does no remain static.... Kamal |
|||
|
|
Das könnte Dich auch interessieren: |
Sony GNV-111D Vs GNZ-9D davis8673 am 11.01.2006 – Letzte Antwort am 12.03.2006 – 2 Beiträge |
TV - which is better.Sony Wega or Philips? juggy_25 am 10.07.2006 – Letzte Antwort am 09.10.2006 – 32 Beiträge |
Foren Archiv
2006
Anzeige
Produkte in diesem Thread
Aktuelle Aktion
Top 10 Threads der letzten 7 Tage
- Hotel Modus deaktivieren
- "diese anwendung wird jetzt neu gestartet um mehr speicherplatz verfügbar zu machen"
- Von HD+ zurück zu Standard-TV
- Remotekabel anschließen, aber wie und wo?
- Hisense verbindet sich nicht mehr mit dem WLAN
- Audiodeskription ausschalten (in ZDF App) 803er
- Umschalten von TV auf Radio
- Satellitenschüssel was und wie einstellen am TV
- Pro 7 und Sat 1 auf einmal weg.
- Markierung an Lautsprecherkabel - welche Norm?
Top 10 Threads der letzten 50 Tage
- Hotel Modus deaktivieren
- "diese anwendung wird jetzt neu gestartet um mehr speicherplatz verfügbar zu machen"
- Von HD+ zurück zu Standard-TV
- Remotekabel anschließen, aber wie und wo?
- Hisense verbindet sich nicht mehr mit dem WLAN
- Audiodeskription ausschalten (in ZDF App) 803er
- Umschalten von TV auf Radio
- Satellitenschüssel was und wie einstellen am TV
- Pro 7 und Sat 1 auf einmal weg.
- Markierung an Lautsprecherkabel - welche Norm?
Top 10 Suchanfragen
Forumsstatistik
- Registrierte Mitglieder926.761 ( Heute: 6 )
- Neuestes Mitgliedanton.ente
- Gesamtzahl an Themen1.553.894
- Gesamtzahl an Beiträgen21.600.980